How to Make the BEST BLT

I know you’re probably thinking that you don’t need a recipe for a BLT…the ingredients are in the name of the sandwich, right? I have a few tricks to take your average BLT and make it the BEST BLT ever!

Ok, so growing up my parents were garden people, and on top of the horror of having to weed the garden all the time as a kid, they also would eat raw tomatoes with a little salt like it was an apple. The horror!

And now here we are, once again the enemy called “time” has taught me that “yeah behold I know that I am nothing” (Alma 26:12) because sure enough, there’s nothing more incredible than a garden tomato. The grocery store might as well rename their tomatoes because they are not the same thing. My mom would practically salivate at the mention of a BLT and now I’m totally wiping my keyboard clean as I do the same.

Tips for the BEST BLT

We know there aren’t a ton of ingredients in a BLT sandwich so the ingredients need to be done right! Here are our tips for BLT success:

Bread

We prefer a good high quality sourdough bread sliced fairly thin — about 1/2 inch thick. If you aren’t a sour dough fan, then do a good sturdy white bread or french bread.

PRO TIP: Give up the toaster and grill each slice of bread in butter (not bacon fat!) on a cast iron skillet only on one side. This way, the inside remains tender. Don’t over toast the bread! You are looking for a nice light golden brown.

Mayo

Mayo…it can be such a divisive subject! Ha! You either love it or hate it, and if you love it, then you have your favorite brand. If you hate it, then you probably aren’t a BLT fan, because BLT’s must have mayo. It’s just not right without it!

If you love it, then for this recipe, it doesn’t matter what brand is your favorite, just make sure it is a high quality mayo. Duke’s is my preferred brand, but Hellman’s or Miracle Whip are great as well.

You’re going to make a sort of aioli out of the mayo. Mix in the garlic (a MUST) and a tiny squeeze of lemon juice (if desired though it’s optional) and mix everything together. Spread on the inside of BOTH slices of the bread.

Tomato

If you can get your hands on some fresh garden tomatoes (preferably beefsteak) or some from a farm stand, then definitely do that! If it’s not tomato season, then go with beefsteaks from the grocery store.

PRO TIP: Slice the tomatoes in nice thick slices, and season them well with salt and pepper.

Lettuce

You want to have multiple leaves of lettuce layered in your sandwich so you get that nice fresh crunch! Iceberg lettuce or green leaf are our preferred types.

Bacon

People often think, the thicker the slice of bacon, the better, and normally I would not disagree! But for BLTs, I’ve actually found that thin or medium slices is best so you don’t pull out all of the bacon when you’re trying to get a bite.

You want it really crisp and brittle for the best texture combination and ease of eating. Head to our post on how to cook bacon for instructions on how to cook perfect bacon.

How to Make a BLT Video

Ways to Augment BLTs

Ok, you don’t need to add anything to these sandwiches because they are heaven, but if you want to experiment, here are some ideas to add to them:

Fried Egg
Avocado
Roasted Red Peppers
Coleslaw
Hummus

What to Eat with a BLT

You can totally make a meal out of these outrageous BLTs by adding a simple side or two. We love to eat them with some grilled corn on the cob and a summer fruit salad or a tomato cucumber salad with some french fries. If you’re craving a BLT in the fall or winter, they go so great with soups and chili!

Can You Make BLTs Ahead of Time?

Yes, they make a great sandwich to pack for school lunch or to take to work. Make sure you pack the tomatoes separately because they will make your bread all soggy. I like to put them in a little container and add them right before eating the sandwich.

How Long Do BLTs Keep?

Once BTLs have been assembled, they do not keep long. The tomatoes can quickly make the bread and bacon soggy, so it is best if they are eaten fresh.

The perfect BEST BLT should be juicy but never soggy, crispy but also tender, and buttery toasted golden. This is that recipe! BLTs are great for a quick dinner or for a delicious lunch. Follow all our tips and you’ll never make BTLs another way again!

More Sandwich Recipes You’ll Love:

Launched!

Our new book is now available!

From food prep to clean-up, this unique cookbook guides the way through every step, including meal lists and easy-to-follow recipes, and features dollops of heartwarming family stories, insights, and kid-friendly food activities to keep young chefs focused on fun in the kitchen.

Buy now